Erica Goldson shocked her school and then the internet by criticizing our education system in her valedictorian speech. Click the play button above or download the interview below to hear about Erica's experiences as a student and her unconventional ideas on improving education.

UPDATE: Since the interview, Erica and I discovered that we share a deep love of learning through discussion and open-minded debate, so we've joined forces in bringing more voices and ears to the conversation about education.

We will now be taking turns posting interviews with passionate educators, parents, and students, so be sure to subscribe for updates and join us on Facebook to follow the bouncing around of ideas that will ensue on a weekly basis.
erica.mp3
File Size: 28941 kb
File Type: mp3
Download File

 


Comments

Gene Koszio

Wed, 06 Oct 2010 10:21:43 pm

In short the public schools, including the universities, are nothing more than baby-sitting institutions.

 

Tania

Tue, 12 Oct 2010 2:00:57 pm

I'd say they're worse than that, Gene. At least baby sitters let you play!

 

Self-educated

Tue, 19 Oct 2010 11:45:41 am

Sadly, this speak sounded well thought out until the last line.

'But first, let's go get those pieces of paper that tell us we're smart enough to do so.'

If the modern school system in the US is simply turning out mindless drones, is it really wise to base your opinions of people's level of intellect on a piece of paper from an extension of that same school system? Wouldn't it be wiser to deprive that extension of much of its funding by refusing to buy into the 'paper equals smart' myth?

What amuses me is the fact that I do not have a college degree, which has saved me from a much larger load of debt and has kept me from being the usual massive drain on taxpayer funding. Not only that, but I have tutored college seniors, been told that I seem far smarter than the college professors they pay to learn from, and have been asked if my Master's degree was from Harvard or Yale.

Many were shocked to learn that my higher education was self-education and did not involve an insanely high tuition, frat and sorority drunk-fests, or sitting in a classroom for years on end.

Of course, when asked to justify getting a college education, most college faculty state that they FEEL college is the right way to learn. Students state that higher earnings were their goal-completely missing the irony that the higher earnings are canceled out by the higher debts incurred.

College may have been useful and productive in the days of Plato and Socrates, but it has far outstayed its usefulness, and in my opinion, its welcome.

 

Tania

Tue, 19 Oct 2010 11:55:08 am

Hi, Self-educated!

I'm pretty sure Erica was being fully ironic with that last sentence. The entire point of her speech was that intelligence and learning are not supported by schools.

As for the value of a college education, would you say college "isn't for everyone" or that it is for no-one (meaning, that it is almost always a waste of time and money)?

 



Leave a Reply